I've only ever used Tanners but I didn't realize how small these bottles were going to be. I was a little disappointed with the shipping cost here for a single bottle. I should have bought 3 when I ordered. The product is solid but I can't compare it to other products on the market (the leather has a great feel to it once treated). The spray soaks in quickly into the leather without wiping. If you are breaking in a new glove you might need 2 bottles depending on what you are looking for in the leather (but 1 was skimpy). Tanners get 5 stars, shipping here gets a 3. Same shipping price here for 3.