The Best Catcher’s Mitts for 2021 (with reviews)

A catcher's equipment needs are much more personalized than any other position on the field, and this is especially true when it comes to catcher's mitts. Catcher's mitts come in a variety of styles, so it's important to make sure that you find the right one for your comfort and a style of play. Here, we’re breaking down a list of the top seven mitts to review before you buy. 

 To see more options, check out our full selection of catcher’s mitts.

 

In this article, we’ll cover:

  • List of the Best Baseball Catcher’s Mitts
  • How to Size Your Catcher’s Mitt
  • Best Catcher’s Gloves by Category
  • Which Brands Make the Best Catcher’s Mitts?

The Best Catcher’s Mitts Reviewed by BaseballMonkey

Rank

Image

Name

Top Benefit

1

Wilson A2000 M2 SuperSkin

A mix of Pro Stock leather and Wilson’s SuperSkin makes this glove durable without sacrificing performance.

2

Rawlings Pro Preferred PROSCM43C

With a combination of professional game-day patterns and pro-grade materials, the Rawlings Pro delivers performance game after game.

3

All-Star Pro Elite CM3000SBT 

Crafted from dried Japanese steer hide, the All-Pro Elite is designed for catchers who prefer a stiffer glove.

4

Rawlings Heart of the Hide Hypershell PROCM41BCF

This Rawlings catcher’s mitt has a one-piece solid web design, a thermoformed hand opening, and padded thumb for extra comfort.

5

Wilson A2K M5

1D

Hand-built from high-end materials, the Wilson A2K catcher’s mitt is designed for elite players who are looking for a combination of comfort, durability, and performance.

6

Rawlings Gold Glove Series RGGCM43MO

This one-piece webbed catcher’s mitt has a shell crafted from European leather and padded with a 100% wool blend for added comfort. 

7

Rawlings Encore ECCM32-23BW

The Rawlings Encore series is engineered for those looking to improve their catching skills. Designed to be game-ready, the break-in time on this glove is shorter than most other catcher’s mitts.

 

1. Wilson A2000 M2 SuperSkin

Wilson A2000 M2 SuperSkin 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt - 2021 ModelWilson A2000 M2 SuperSkin 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt - 2021 Model

Type: Baseball; Catcher's Mitt

Overview: Wilson has combined natural Pro Stock leather and engineered SuperSkin to make their A2000 M2 series catcher's glove stronger, lighter, and more durable. With a half-moon web, this glove is easy to break in and will stand up to the rigors of the catching position season after season.

Key Features:

  • Half-moon web
  • Crafted from lightweight materials
  • Reduced break-in time

2. Rawlings Pro Preferred PROSCM43C

Rawlings Pro Preferred PROSCM43C 34" Baseball Catcher's MittRawlings Pro Preferred PROSCM43C 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

Type: Baseball; Catcher's Mitt

Overview: Rawlings designed their Pro Preferred catcher's mitt series to look clean and adapt to individual players’ catching styles. Supple kip leather provides a softness and durability that puts up with the abuse the best catcher's gloves take, without giving in.

Key Features:

  • One-piece solid web
  • 70% player break-in
  • Pro Preferred kip leather shell

3. All-Star Pro Elite CM3000SBT  

All-Star Pro Elite CM3000SBT 33.5" Baseball Catcher's MittAll-Star Pro Elite CM3000SBT 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

Type: Baseball; Catcher's Mitt

Overview: The All-Star Pro Elite catcher's mitt is designed specifically for catchers who like a stiffer glove. Crafted from Japanese tanned steer hide, this mitt gives catchers that stiff experience without sacrificing performance. The soft pocket provides the "pop" that pitchers love to hear when the ball hits their glove.

Key Features:

  • Designed for a stiffer experience
  • Handcrafted
  • Black leather backing for extended life

4. Rawlings Heart of the Hide Hypershell PROCM41BCF 

Rawlings Heart of the Hide Hypershell PROCM41BCF 34" Baseball Catcher's MittRawlings Heart of the Hide Hypershell PROCM41BCF 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

Type: Baseball; Catcher's Mitt

Overview: The Rawlings Heart of the Hyde Hypershell catcher's mitt is built from materials that make it 15-percent lighter than traditional baseball catcher’s glove models. With a thermoformed hand opening and padded thumb sleeve, this mitt is designed with comfort in mind.

Key Features:

  • One-piece solid web
  • 60% player break in
  • Conventional back

5. Wilson A2K M1D 

Wilson A2K M1D 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt - 2021 ModelWilson A2K M1D 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt - 2021 Model

Type: Baseball; Catcher's Mitt

Overview: The Wilson A2K M1D is the pinnacle of Wilson catcher's mitts. Handcrafted from flawless leather, this glove will hold a perfect shape longer than conventional catcher's mitts. It provides catchers with an unparalleled elite experience.

Key Features:

  • Double-palm construction
  • Half-moon web
  • Features Pro Stock Select leather

6. Rawlings Gold Glove Series RGGCM43MO 

Rawlings Gold Glove Series RGGCM43MO 34" Baseball Catcher's MittRawlings Gold Glove Series RGGCM43MO 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

Type: Baseball; Catcher's Mitt

Overview: The Rawlings Gold Glove Series is a top-of-the-line catcher's mitt. Crafted from quality European leather, this catcher's glove is designed to last longer than most catcher's mitts while performing at an elite level.

Key Features:

  • One-piece solid web
  • 100% wool padding
  • European leather shell

7. Rawlings Encore ECCM32-23BW 

Rawlings Encore ECCM32-23BW 32" Baseball Catcher's MittRawlings Encore ECCM32-23BW 32" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

Type: Baseball; Catcher's Mitt

Overview: Designed for catchers looking to improve their game, the Rawlings Encore series has a deeper pocket for control and protection. This catcher's mitt comes with a game-ready feel significantly reducing the work and time needed to break it in.

Key Features:

  • Deep pocket
  • Reduced break in time
  • Adjustable pull lace wrist opening

How to Size Your Catcher’s Mitt

For performance and protection, it’s vital that you choose the correct size of catcher’s mitt. You can either try on various-sized catcher’s mitts to gauge your size, or you can use the chart below to find the appropriate range for the age of the catcher.

 

In general, you can use the following guidelines as a starting point:

 

Baseball Catcher’s Mitt Sizing by Age

7 & Under: 29.5 - 30"

Ages 8-10: 30 - 31"

11-13: 30 - 34.5"

14+: 32 - 34.5"

 

Fastpitch Catcher’s Mitt Sizing by Age

7 & Under: 29.5 - 30"

Ages 8-10: 30 - 32"

11-13: 31 - 32.5"

14+: 33 - 35"


See our complete guide to find out what size catcher’s mitt you need.

Best Catcher’s Gloves by Category

Not all catcher’s mitts are the same. Depending on your age and level of play, the best catcher’s mitt may vary. Check out the list below for suggestions on what may be the best glove for your game.

Best High School/College Catcher’s Mitt

Wilson A2K M1D: The Wilson A2K is designed to put up with the rigors of the catching position. This glove should last for several seasons of high school or college baseball. Crafted from Pro Stock leather, the focus on the design allows for consistency in performance without sacrificing durability or comfort. The double-palm construction makes the pocket more stable, offering better control.

Best Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Rawlings Encore ECCM32-23BW: The Rawlings Encore series is our best youth catcher's glove for players learning how to play the position. Its deeper pocket helps retain possession of pitches as well as reduce the sting of fastballs. With a pull lace wrist strap, younger players can adjust the tightness to improve comfort levels, and a game-ready feel reduces break-in time, relieving youth players from this potentially frustrating process.

Best Fastpitch Softball Glove

Wilson A2000 CM34 SuperSkin Fastpitch Catcher’s Mitt: The Wilson A2000 CM34 SuperSkin fastpitch catcher’s mitt utilizes the same construction as their A2000 SuperSkin baseball catcher’s mitt line, adapted to the needs of a softball fastpitch catcher. The combination of natural leather and Wilson’s engineered SuperSkin gives this glove great durability, comfort level, and a lightweight experience.

Best Value Catcher’s Glove

Rawlings Heart of the Hide Hypershell PROCM41BCF: Crafted to be 15 percent lighter than traditional catcher's mitts, the Rawlings Heart of the Hide Hypershell gives catchers consistent performance without the price tag of a higher-end model. This mitt has a one-piece solid web for control and a traditional back. A thermoformed hand opening and padded thumb sleeve make this our best value catcher's mitt.

Find the Best Selection of Catcher’s Mitts at BaseballMonkey!

Now that you’ve learned more about some of the best catcher’s gloves on the market, you’re ready to begin browsing our full selection of catcher’s mitts.