The Best Catcher’s Mitts for 2023 (with reviews)
A catcher's equipment needs are much more personalized than any other position on the field, and this is especially true when it comes to catcher's mitts. Catcher's mitts come in a variety of styles, so it's important to make sure that you find the right one for your comfort and a style of play. Here, we’re breaking down a list of the top seven mitts to review before you buy.
To see more options, check out our full selection of catcher’s mitts.
In this article, we’ll cover:
- List of the Best Baseball Catcher’s Mitts
- How to Size Your Catcher’s Mitt
- Best Catcher’s Gloves by Category
- Which Brands Make the Best Catcher’s Mitts?
The Best Catcher’s Mitts Reviewed by BaseballMonkey
A high-caliber player deserves a high-caliber glove, and All-Star delivers with the Pro Elite CM3000SBT. The Pro Elite CM3000SBT features exclusive Japanese tanned steer hide and is perfect for the catcher who wants a stiffer glove. Black leather on the backing of the CM3000SBT is stiffer and provides support to extend the life of the glove.
- Exclusive Japanese tanned steer hide
- Soft tan leather pocket allows for a great feel and POP sound pitchers and catchers love
- Adjustable wrist opening for a custom fit to the player’s hand
The Rawlings Encore 32” catcher’s mitt is a great combination of quality and affordability! Encore catcher’s mitts feature anti-sting technology in the palm and a faster break-in time compared to other Rawlings gloves. Encore includes an inventive web and a deep pocket that allows the fingers to close around the web while still maintaining the pocket shape.
- Faster break-in that maintains its shape
- Anti-sting technology in the palm
- Adjustable hand opening for a custom fit
Known for their top-of-the-line catcher’s gear, All Star Pro CM3100SBT 33.5” catcher’s mitt delivers a high-performing glove with a shorter break-in time. The CM3100 series features Japanese tanned U.S. steer hide and heavy-duty rawhide laces. This series also includes extended pockets on the mitt and great support within the glove which helps extend the life of the mitt.
- Japanese tanned U.S. steer hide
- Adjustable velcro wrist opening for a custom fit
- Designed for a fast break-in time
Rawling's world-renowned Heart of the Hide series is of the highest quality you will find in baseball. This mitt is constructed from top-grade U.S. steer hide leather and features Rawling’s HyperShell backhand which reduces weight and adds durability. “The Finest in the Field” includes a deer-tanned cowhide palm and soft full-grain finger back linings for added comfortability.
- Top-grade U.S. steer hide leather
- HyperShell backhand reduces weight and adds durability
- Padded thumb sleeve and thermoformed wrist opening for added comfort
Another great option for a catcher’s mitt is to fully customize your mitt with the Rawlings Glove Customizer. This gives you the option to pick the type of leather, the color of the leather, the color of the laces, and much more to make it uniquely your glove. The customizer allows you to pick either Rawlings Pro Preferred, Heart of the Hide, or Gamer XLE series gloves to customize.
- Full-customization of catcher’s mitt
- Different options for wrist opening for a true custom fit
- A unique glove that is truly one-of-one
This Rawlings Heart of the Hide PROCM-33T 33” catcher’s mitt features a classic colorway and the same Heart of the Hide quality baseball players know and love. Constructed from top-grade U.S. steer hide, this glove is sure to hold up over time. Heart of the Hide series gloves also includes a deer tanned cowhide palm lining and soft full-grain finger back linings for increased comfortability.
- Top-grade U.S. steer hide
- Thermoformed hand opening and padded thumb for comfort
- Pro-grade leather laces to add durability and strength
The pinnacle of Rawlings baseball gloves is their Pro Preferred series. Pro Preferred catcher’s mitts are known for their clean, supple kip leather, while also helping players create the perfect pocket. This catcher’s mitt also features 100% wool padding to help maintain shape and a Pittard’s sheep skin palm lining to wick away moisture while adding superior comfort.
- Full-grain kip leather provides an unrivaled look and feel
- Pittard’s sheep skin palm lining provides comfortability and wicks away moisture
- Each Pro Preferred glove includes an individual identification number
The Wilson A2K M1D catcher’s mitt is part of Wilson’s premier glove series, the A2K. This catcher’s mitt features Wilson’s Pro Stock leather which is chosen for its consistency and flawlessness. Double palm construction on this mitt creates a more stable pocket and allows the player to better maintain the shape of the glove/pocket. Made for the elite player, this catcher’s mitt is extremely durable and will last years.
- Snakeskin leather backhand
- Pro Stock leather is known for its consistency and flawlessness
- Double palm construction makes for a more stable pocket
All-Star’s Pro Elite catcher’s mitts are top-tier when it comes to getting a quality glove. With exclusive Japanese tanned steer hide and all-black leather for a stiffer glove, it’s no wonder why this glove is a top choice for several professional baseball catchers. Each of these Pro Elite mitts are handmade and contain only the finest materials.
- Adjustable wrist opening for a custom fit
- Exclusive Japanese tanned steer hide
- All black leather provides a stiffer but more durable glove
How to Size Your Catcher’s Mitt
For performance and protection, it’s vital that you choose the correct size of catcher’s mitt. You can either try on various-sized catcher’s mitts to gauge your size, or you can use the chart below to find the appropriate range for the age of the catcher.
In general, you can use the following guidelines as a starting point:
Baseball Catcher’s Mitt Sizing by Age
7 & Under: 29.5 - 30"
Ages 8-10: 30 - 31"
11-13: 30 - 34.5"
14+: 32 - 34.5"
Fastpitch Catcher’s Mitt Sizing by Age
7 & Under: 29.5 - 30"
Ages 8-10: 30 - 32"
11-13: 31 - 32.5"
14+: 33 - 35"
See our complete guide to find out what size catcher’s mitt you need.
Best Catcher’s Gloves by Category
Not all catcher’s mitts are the same. Depending on your age and level of play, the best catcher’s mitt may vary. Check out the list below for suggestions on what may be the best glove for your game.
Best High School/College Catcher’s Mitt
Best Youth Catcher’s Mitt
Rawlings R9 Series 32" Baseball Catcher's Mitt - 2023 Model: Rawlings’ R9 Series catcher’s mitt is the best youth catcher’s mitt as it features soft tumbled full-grain leather as well as a pro-style pattern. R9 series provides the perfect combination of durability and comfortability for the young ballplayer. Rawlings has included a reinforced palm pad, padded finger back linings, padded thumb loops, and a Boa hand opening for unrivaled comfort.
Best Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Glove
Rawlings Heart of the Hide PROCM33FP-24G 33" Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt - 2022 Model: Known for their premium quality in baseball, it comes as no surprise that Rawlings has brought that same Heart of the Hide quality to softball! The Heart of the Hide series is known for its full-grain leather to enhance durability but Rawlings has also included a padded thumb sleeve to enhance player comfort. For the fastpitch softball catcher, this glove features pull-strap closures on the hand opening to give the player a custom fit.
Best Value Catcher’s Glove
Rawlings Heart of the Hide PROCM33T 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt - 2022 Model: The best value catcher’s glove goes to the Rawlings Heart of the Hide PROCM33T. This mitt is extremely durable with full-grain Rawlings Heart of the Hide leather and a deer tanned cowhide palm lining. The palm lining paired with soft full-grain finger back linings provide the player with a comfortable feel. Lastly, Rawlings has added a padded thumb sleeve to this mitt, providing added support and comfort to the catcher’s thumb.
Find the Best Selection of Catcher’s Mitts at BaseballMonkey!
Now that you’ve learned more about some of the best catcher’s gloves on the market, you’re ready to begin browsing our full selection of catcher’s mitts.
This article was originally published on June 16, 2021, and has been updated with new information.